Carnelian Property Management Newcastle
  • Home
  • Contact
  • About
    • 7 Great Reasons To Work With Us
    • Steps In Managing Your Investment Property
    • Testimonials
    • About The Team
    • What We Do
  • Rental Appraisal
  • Switch to Us
  • For Lease
  • PropertySnacks
  • Blog
We provide expert property management in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie.  Based in Charlestown NSW, we have been delighting Newcastle property investors with our personal, professional service since 2011.

Find out the 7 great reasons to work with us, and if you find this article helpful or enjoyable, please subscribe or share it with someone else who may benefit.

Higher Rent vs Minimum Vacancy vs Quality Tenancy: The 3-Way Balance In Setting Ideal Rent

11/10/2021

0 Comments

 
3 way balance of setting ideal rent - carnelian property management newcastle
This week we were engaged in a discussion with some industry peers around the need to consider more than just the dollar value when setting rent for an investment property. Below, we share a real-world example of the outcome of an investor seeking high rent above other considerations, and the avoidable results of this approach. 

In the process we introduce the 3-Way Balance of Setting The Ideal Rent. 

The Real-World Example of Seeking High Rent Above All Else

A number of years ago, we had a meeting with an investor who was buying an off-the-plan apartment close to Newcastle Beach. At the time he advised us that he was seeking $800+ per week in rent.

In response, our estimate at the time based on market conditions and oversupply of similar offerings was $670-$700 per week. For a number of reasons (differences in rental expectation being one of them!), we didn't end up working together. 

Looking back now on what ended up happening with this property, we see:
  • It was first listed for $780pw (approximately $100pw above our recommendation)
  • It was advertised on market for 2 months before the asking rent was dropped to $750pw
  • The property was removed from advertising (presumably filled at $750pw) after 85 days on market.

In summary, throughout its first campaign, the property was listed for roughly $80 more than we estimated, and was vacant for at least 85 days (approx. 12 weeks). 

Holding onto the "ideal" of high rent resulted in 12 weeks of vacancy for $80 extra rent i.e. this approach cost the investor $960 in rent while waiting!

Holding out for high rent resulted in 12 weeks of vacancy for $80 extra  per week. This approach cost the investor $960 in rent while waiting.

And if that wasn't enough...

Records show that this same property listed again 6 months later. 

Just think about this. Not only did the investor lose out on almost $1,000 in rental income while waiting for somebody to pay the requested high rent, the tenant who went into the property obviously was not a quality long-term tenant, and the process needed to start all over again only 6 months down the track.

When the property listed for the second time:
  • It listed again for the premium asking rent of $780 pw
  • Again, it was reduced after 2 months but this time all the way to $700pw instead of $750 as previously
  • After a further 3 months rent was lowered again to $680pw "including 2 weeks free rent"
  • It was eventually removed from advertising after an excruciating 149 days on market.

​Not only did the investor lose out on almost $1,000 in rental income while waiting for somebody to pay the requested high rent, the tenant who  eventually went into the property left after only 6 months and the leasing process had to start all over again.
So, in this second round of long term vacancy, the property remained entirely non-income producing for 21 weeks, off the back of a 12 week vacancy in the previous year. 

In total, this high rent objective resulted in 32 weeks of vacancy over the course of approximately 18 months. That is, the property sat vacant producing no income for 40% of the time over an 18 month period. 

​In total, this high rent objective resulted in 32 weeks of vacancy over the course of approximately 18 months. That is, the property sat vacant producing no income for 40% of the time over an 18 month period. 

The 3-Way Balance of Setting The Ideal Rent

This above case is extreme, but it is also real and is not uncommon.

We so often speak with investors who either have inflated ideas of what the property is worth on the rental market, or have been mislead by agencies estimating very high rent to secure the listing. 
​
It's like the old saying "Good; fast; cheap - choose two". When setting the rent for an investment there needs to be a balance between 3 factors: rent, vacancy, quality tenancy. 

The 3-Way Balance of Setting Ideal Rent

As the focus shifts towards obtaining the highest rent, the vacancy period increases and number of quality tenants to choose from reduces. 

Likewise if the focus is on minimum vacancy period, you may not receive optimal rent and could be filling the vacancy with a low-quality applicant. 

And last, if the focus is on finding a quality long-term tenant, there sometimes needs to be an acceptance that highest rent may not be achieved, and/or that finding that applicant can take a little longer.

Which Of The 3 Rental Elements Should Never Be Compromised?

Of the three of these measures, it can be argued that one element above the others should not be compromised - quality tenancy.

The reason for this is that the ideal rent is not the highest rent that any tenant will pay, but the highest rent a quality tenant will pay. ​

And from a financial perspective for an investor, a period of vacancy may have a lowering effect on rental yield, but a poor tenant selection in the first instance can have a major impact on the value of the property. 
Ask Us About Your Rental Return
We provide expert property management in Newcastle and Lake Macquarie.  Based in Charlestown NSW, we have been delighting Newcastle property investors with our personal, professional service since 2011.

Find out the 7 great reasons to work with us, and if you found this article helpful or enjoyable, please subscribe or share it with someone else who may benefit.

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Carnelian Property Management Newcastle NSW

    We are a family-owned and run Charlestown real estate agent offering expert property management across Newcastle and Lake Macquarie. 
    ​Get to know us here.


    Want More?

    Build your property management knowledge - get regular tips and advice for landlords and tenants straight to your inbox.
    Subscribe

    Categories

    All
    Adverse Possession
    Advertising
    Agency Agreement
    Choosing An Agent
    COVID 19
    COVID-19
    Finance
    First Home Owner Grant
    Furnished
    Insurance
    Investment Property
    Lake Macquarie Life
    Landlord Responsibilities
    Lease Terms
    Moving House
    Negative Gearing
    Newcastle Life
    Newcastle Property Management
    Pets
    Positive Gearing
    Preparing A Rental Property
    Property Management Costs
    Property Management Statistics
    PropertySnacks
    Rental Appraisal
    Rental Yield
    Rent Review
    Research
    Routine Inspections
    Saving Money
    Suburb Profiles
    Tenant Responsibilities
    Vacancy Rates


    Archives

    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017


    RSS Feed

Carnelian Property Management
1A Chapman St Charlestown NSW 2290
​ph: 02 4062 7458 (tenant / general enquiries)
m: 0407 065 126 (investor enquiries)
Facebook - Property Management in Newcastle - Carnelian Property Management
Instagram - Property Management in Newcastle - Carnelian Property Management
Subscribe to Email
​Request a Rental Appraisal
Rental Application Form
Lost Keys / Locked Out Policy
​Cleaning Checklist
Submit Maintenance Request
​Tenant Portal
​Investor Portal

Copyright © 2022 Carnelian Property Management in Newcastle NSW | ABN 18 624 074 077. Privacy Policy | Complaint Procedure
Facebook - Property Management in Newcastle - Carnelian Property Management
Instagram - Property Management in Newcastle - Carnelian Property Management
Subscribe to email
Request a rental appraisal
Rental application form
Lost Keys / Locked Out Policy
Cleaning checklist
Submit Maintenance Request
Tenant Portal
Investor Portal
Carnelian Property Management
1A Chapman St Charlestown NSW 2290
​ph: 02 4062 7458 (tenant / general enquiries)
m: 0407 065 126 (investor enquiries)
Submit maintenance request

​Copyright © 2022 Carnelian Property Management in Newcastle NSW
​ABN
18 624 074 077
Complaint Procedure
Privacy Policy
  • Home
  • Contact
  • About
    • 7 Great Reasons To Work With Us
    • Steps In Managing Your Investment Property
    • Testimonials
    • About The Team
    • What We Do
  • Rental Appraisal
  • Switch to Us
  • For Lease
  • PropertySnacks
  • Blog